Episode 433: The Leech

Episode 424 • November 16, 2026 • 00:45:41
Episode 433: The  Leech
The Mysterious Old Radio Listening Society
Episode 433: The Leech

Nov 16 2026 | 00:45:41

/

Show Notes

Peter Lorre welcomes us to Nightmare, the fourth of ten episodes listening to a radio series we have not yet featured on the podcast! The story features a wife and her lover who intend to confront her husband and demand a divorce. But their plans take a sudden turn and they find themselves trying to get rid of a corpse! Will they free themselves from this dead body? Has some supernatural force locked itself in a closet? Will this be the episode that we don’t actually discuss afterwards, but simply shrug at instead? Listen for yourself and find out!

View Full Transcript

Episode Transcript

[00:00:16] Speaker A: The Mysterious Old Radio Listening Society podcast. [00:00:27] Speaker B: Welcome to the Mysterious Old Radio Listening Society, a podcast dedicated to suspense, crime and horror stories from the golden age of radio. I'm Eric. [00:00:36] Speaker C: I'm Tim. And I'm Joshua. We love mysterious old time radio stories, but do they Stand the test of time? That's what we're here to find out. To mark our 10th anniversary, we're featuring a series of 10 old time radio programs never discussed on the podcast before. Today we present program number four, Nightmare. [00:00:54] Speaker B: Nightmare is a half hour horror anthology broadcast on the Mutual Network from October 1953 to October 19, 1954. Produced in Hollywood, the series featured Peter Lorre as its host and narrator, introducing stories of crime, psychological terror and the supernatural. [00:01:12] Speaker C: Born Laszlo Lowenstein in 1904 in what was then Austria, Hungary, Peter Lorre worked in European theater before moving to Berlin. His breakout role was as the child murderer in Fritz Lang's landmark sound film M, released in 1931. A Jewish actor, Laurie fled Germany after Hitler rose to power, eventually settling in Great Britain where he made his English language film debut in Alfred Hitchcock's the Man who Knew Too Much. After moving to Hollywood, he played Dr. Gogol in the 1935 horror film Mad Love. Although the film performed poorly at the American box office, critics praised the maniacal intensity of Lorre's performance. During the 1940s, Laurie appeared in a string of film classics, including the Maltese Falcon, Casablanca, and Arsenic and Old Lace. Despite his range as an actor, he was frequently typecast as a sinister outsider or murderous madman. His distinctive voice, with its ability to move instantly from a tranquil will whisper to a baleful roar, was especially effective on radio, where he appeared on programs such as Suspense and inner sanctum. [00:02:15] Speaker B: In 1947, NBC's Mystery in the Air gave him a sustained showcase, casting him in the leading roles and adaptations of literary tales of mystery and terror. When he returned with Nightmare in 1953, his role was different. Rather than playing the central characters, Laurie served as host and narrator, guiding listeners into stories performed by other actors. [00:02:37] Speaker D: A quick heads up before we begin. This recording has a few sound issues. In particular, Peter Lorre's introduction gradually speeds up, giving us a few seconds of what he might have sounded like as Alvin the Chipmunk. You're welcome. [00:02:49] Speaker C: So here it is, the Leech from Nightmare, originally broadcast April 7, 1954. [00:02:57] Speaker B: It's late at night and a chill has set in. You're alone and the only light you see is coming from an antique radio. Listen to the sounds coming from the speaker. Listen to the music and listen to the voices [00:03:12] Speaker E: out of the dark of night from the shadows of the senses convicts the fantasy of fear nightmare starring as your exciting guide to terror. Peter Lorry. Did you ever have a dream? A dream in which you were running and running and running away from some incomesque horrible things that were after you to kill you? Oh yes. And you scream and you keep running, but yet it runs too. And no matter how you run or how fast you run, it's still after you. This thing. This thing runs fast and you enter and you can get away from it. No matter where you turn, you can't get away from it. And you wake up and you know you've been dreaming. But the sweats over your body like a wet shroud. And your heart, it beats wildly. And you find that you're still screaming. Because even though you're awake, that thing is still there in the room with you. It clings. It clings like a leech. I know the story of a man and a leech he couldn't get away from. But in this story the leech was dead and he was human. You are listening to Peter Laurie tell you of the leech. Another transcribed story of nightmare. How about this man, Nameless Tom Tom fell. Nice young man, ordinarily likable. His nightmare started the day he fell in love. Oh, Iris. She was beautiful, like the flower she was named after. But this Iris, she had sworn detached Irish, was married, looking out the window. Well, why take a chance always? Why take a chance always looking over the shoulder to see if we're being watched. Oh, don't. Another cigarette in another doorway. A few quiet puffs, a weak smile [00:05:26] Speaker F: and another separation. [00:05:27] Speaker E: Well, what can I do about it? You [00:05:28] Speaker F: could break it clean one way or the other. [00:05:29] Speaker E: What are you talking about? You know [00:05:30] Speaker F: what I mean. Iris, you can tell him or tell me. [00:05:32] Speaker E: Oh, Tom. [00:05:33] Speaker F: Iris, there's just no sense in it this way. [00:05:35] Speaker E: Well, what could I tell him? Tell him the [00:05:36] Speaker F: truth, that's what. Tell him you're in love with me. [00:05:39] Speaker E: Tell [00:05:39] Speaker F: him we want to make our lives together, [00:05:40] Speaker E: Mom. [00:05:40] Speaker F: Tell him you want a divorce. [00:05:43] Speaker E: All right, I'll tell him. [00:05:45] Speaker F: When? [00:05:45] Speaker E: Tonight. Now come on, let's go up. [00:05:48] Speaker F: Both of us. Me? [00:05:50] Speaker E: Well, why not? You're part of it, aren't you? Or are you afraid? [00:05:55] Speaker F: No. No, I'm not afraid. Come on, we'll see him now. [00:06:09] Speaker E: I hate those self service elevators. I'm always afraid of getting stuck. But they're too cheap around here to have any operators at night. Well, are you sure? Now? [00:06:20] Speaker F: Yes, yes, I'm sure. Go on, open the door. Yeah. No, no, no. I think I better try to get a postponement. Yeah, yeah, I'll let you know. Yeah, fine. [00:06:37] Speaker E: Hello, Peter. [00:06:38] Speaker F: Well, well, this is a surprise. Surprise. Didn't expect to see you here, Tom. Well, I. I happened to meet Iris on the street. Uh huh. Well, while he's here, how about a drink? Yeah, it's a good idea. No, [00:06:48] Speaker E: we don't want a drink, Peter. [00:06:50] Speaker F: I've got some good scotch. What do you say, Tom? No, [00:06:52] Speaker E: Tom doesn't want a drink. [00:06:53] Speaker F: Oh, well. Guess this is the first time you've seen my office, Tom. Yes, yes. Nice. Nice place. Burning the midnight oil, huh? Well, you know how it is. Busy season. I work a lot at night. During the busy season. Yeah, sure. Well, sure you won't have a drink? Sure, I. [00:07:14] Speaker E: Peter, Tom has something to tell you. [00:07:15] Speaker F: Me? You said you. [00:07:17] Speaker E: All right, I'll do it. Just keep quiet. Peter. I think it's about time we stopped playing hide and seek. It's about time you knew, Peter. Time and I. Well, what's so funny? [00:07:37] Speaker F: You can't tell me a thing, Iris either. If you can't tell me a thing I don't already know. Peter, I want to say that you came here to tell me. You're in love. You want a divorce. You want me to step aside. You don't want to hurt me. But don't you think I've known. Now look, Peter. Don't you think I've known for a long time? About the meetings, the cocktail hours, the trip? All right, [00:07:57] Speaker E: so you've known. Maybe it's better this way. We don't have to talk about it now. [00:08:03] Speaker F: That's right. We don't have to talk about it. Only one or two things. First, there'll be no divorce. Now hold on, Peter. You can't do this to Iris. You can't hold her in prisoner when she doesn't want you. Don't tell me to shut up. I love her. I want to give her the things that she deserves. You want you What? You'd kill us? Well, maybe that's a good idea too. I said, Tom, there's not going to be any divorce. Second, I'm going to ruin you. What? I said I'm going to do everything in my power to ruin you. I'll use every ruse I can think of, every trick, take advantage of every influence I can muster. I'll have you disb. Disgraced, talked about, with no chance of practicing in this state. You're insane. Am I? You know I can do it, don't you? You know I've got the power where. You weak p. Coward. Trying to take my wife away from me. You think that's a j. You [00:08:48] Speaker E: pig. [00:08:49] Speaker F: You can't talk about it that way. You just use this. No, no. It's iron. It's heavy. Right. Here. No, no, don't. Don't laugh at me. Laugh at me. No, you won't laugh at me. Laugh at me. You won't laugh at me anymore. You won't stand in my way anymore. You're. Stop. No, you won't. You won't stand it. You're. Stop. [00:09:07] Speaker E: That's enough. That's enough. [00:09:12] Speaker F: Yeah, that's enough. Let him go. Easy. Easy, Iris. Easy. Easy. It's all right. Easy now. [00:09:20] Speaker E: I got to sit [00:09:21] Speaker F: up. Sit down. Here. Sit down. [00:09:23] Speaker E: Oh, Tom. Cover him. Cover him or something. Please. [00:09:26] Speaker F: Take it easy. Here, [00:09:31] Speaker E: Tom. Tom is there. [00:09:33] Speaker F: Yes. Yes. And we're free now, Iris. We're free. [00:09:47] Speaker E: Oh. [00:09:51] Speaker F: You feeling any better? [00:09:52] Speaker E: Yes, I'm all right now. [00:09:54] Speaker F: We've been here too long. 15 minutes. Well, [00:09:56] Speaker E: let's leave. Let's leave now. [00:09:57] Speaker F: Leave it like it is. No. [00:09:58] Speaker E: What do you mean? [00:10:00] Speaker F: If they can't find the body, there's no murder. It's the only way. Nobody saw us come in. That's in our favor. But if we leave him here, we're in for it. No, we'll have to take him. Do something with him. Something. [00:10:12] Speaker E: His eyes are still open. [00:10:13] Speaker F: Stop looking at him. Iris, will you pull out of. [00:10:15] Speaker E: I'm sorry. Only 18th of. He's smiling. Do you want to [00:10:18] Speaker F: call the police now? Get it over with? [00:10:19] Speaker E: No. All right, we'll do it your way. But Jesus. Take. Let's do it. Just come. [00:10:24] Speaker F: I've been thinking. If we just take him out between us, as though he was. Wait. Somebody outside. The cleaning woman. It's the cleaning woman. She's coming this way. A lot to do about that light. Of course, she's got her own key. I forgot. She's got her own key. [00:10:55] Speaker E: Yes, Just a simple little thing like a key. Ordinary, commonplace. But now. Now it takes on a new shape. The shape of a weapon. A weapon turned against Tom and Iris. Key or keys used to open doors. House doors, office doors. And sometimes. Sometimes the doors of a cell. Poor Tom. Poor Iris. Yes, the door is opening. But the door, the open door is a trap. The trap of a L. Living nightmare. Men kill for many different reasons. For money, for love, for power. But whatever the reason, when murder is done, there is always the corpse. The Corpus delicti. The body of the crime. You know, it's. It's not easy to hide a dead body to get rid of a corpse. Tom knows this. Iris knows. But they took a chance. They ran risks. And the running isn't over yet. No, they. They have to get rid of the body. They can't leave it there slumped over the office desk. Cleaning women have eyes, too. Eyes with which to see the shadows cast by a corpse. The shadow that lies over the lights of Tom and Iris. Darkening. Darkening their ill gotten freedom. I don't know. What are we gonna do? [00:12:32] Speaker F: I don't know. Quickly. [00:12:37] Speaker E: Who's that? [00:12:38] Speaker F: Yeah, [00:12:39] Speaker E: somebody in here. [00:12:41] Speaker F: We just came in. [00:12:42] Speaker G: Huh? Didn't see you in the hall. What are you doing here? [00:12:45] Speaker F: Well, [00:12:46] Speaker G: you ain't Mr. Howard. I'm [00:12:47] Speaker E: Mrs. Howard. [00:12:48] Speaker G: We are. Are you? Well, I'm [00:12:50] Speaker E: waiting. I'm waiting for my husband. [00:12:52] Speaker G: That's all right, dear. You just sit down. I'll be finished here in a few minutes. [00:12:56] Speaker F: I wonder if you might come back later. [00:12:57] Speaker G: All the work they put on a toll around here. 20 offices between every night. What wages they call them? Pittance, says I. [00:13:04] Speaker F: There's no need to clean in here. I. [00:13:06] Speaker G: Mr. Howard, there is a sweet soul. Always tips me when he's working nights. Coming back here, we expect him. [00:13:14] Speaker F: Look, I wonder if you could come back later. [00:13:16] Speaker G: Later. Look at this mess. I'll just pick up around that desk. [00:13:20] Speaker F: Stay with my desk [00:13:22] Speaker G: here. Now, what's the matter with you? [00:13:24] Speaker F: I. Nothing's the matter. Just that Mrs. Howard and I have some business to discuss and we'd rather be alone. [00:13:31] Speaker G: You'll be alone as soon as I finish up here. Now, [00:13:34] Speaker F: just a minute. [00:13:35] Speaker G: Not that I can work in this light. Barney can't see it. Stay away in that [00:13:37] Speaker F: light. [00:13:38] Speaker G: But I've got. I [00:13:38] Speaker F: got no way. Do you hear? [00:13:42] Speaker G: Now. Now see what you've gone and done. Turn my tail. [00:13:44] Speaker F: Never mind that. [00:13:45] Speaker G: Never mind, he says. Never mind. The management will be sure of mine if I leave it there. [00:13:50] Speaker F: I'll clean it up and be quick about it. [00:13:51] Speaker G: Don't understand this. I don't. I told you my husband would be back. Don't worry about the tip. I'll tell him to leave it if you're not. He ain't the tip I'm worried about. All right, [00:13:59] Speaker F: all right. Nothing to be cleaned behind that desk. [00:14:02] Speaker G: Now, don't be telling me how to do my job. If you please. Just in case. Just in case he doesn't arrive here. 10. $10. That's what he usually gives you, isn't it? No. I mean, yes, ma'. Am. 10 is what he usually gives me. Now we got to be left alone. We have something to discuss. All right. All right. What [00:14:26] Speaker E: are you laughing at? [00:14:27] Speaker G: Something to discuss. All right, mom. I understand. Mom. I won't be coming back later. Mom. [00:14:44] Speaker E: That old head. Mom, [00:14:46] Speaker G: we've got to get out here. [00:14:46] Speaker E: Sure. Sure we have. [00:14:47] Speaker G: Well, let's go. I want to come. [00:14:48] Speaker E: Leave him here, Iris. Think, will. She's seen us. You gave her your name. Why on earth did you tell her your name? [00:14:53] Speaker G: I didn't. Well, [00:14:54] Speaker E: we've certainly got some thinking to do. We can't leave him here, that's for sure. Well, [00:15:00] Speaker G: how are we going to get him out? [00:15:01] Speaker E: I don't know yet. But if we go without him, we're sure to be just as dead as he is sooner or later. [00:15:15] Speaker G: Any ideas yet? [00:15:16] Speaker E: No. [00:15:18] Speaker G: Stop walking up and down like this. I'm thinking. Well, get out and think. We should. [00:15:25] Speaker E: Cleaning woman. She's still on this floor. You [00:15:26] Speaker G: can't get out if she's in the hall. That's with him. I [00:15:28] Speaker E: know. I know. [00:15:31] Speaker G: Oh, [00:15:32] Speaker E: iris, what's the matter with you? [00:15:33] Speaker G: Tom. Tom. His eyes. They follow me all around. I can't. Will you stop looking at me? I don't care. [00:15:37] Speaker E: Will you stop it? [00:15:42] Speaker G: All right. I'm all right. [00:15:43] Speaker E: Turn the other way. [00:15:44] Speaker G: All right. [00:15:48] Speaker E: Mccaina woman. She'll be going down to the next floor soon. Then we can take him out, hold him between us as if he were drunk. [00:15:56] Speaker G: All right. Anything. Anything. Now, just so long as we do something with him. Get away from him. [00:16:01] Speaker E: What's that? Wait. Somebody coming [00:16:05] Speaker G: in here. [00:16:06] Speaker E: I know that. Come on. Grab his feet. What? We'll put him in the closet. Come on, will you? All right, now, in. Push in. Wait a minute. I'll drag him in. [00:16:21] Speaker G: Look, [00:16:22] Speaker E: if you. [00:16:22] Speaker F: If [00:16:22] Speaker E: you only [00:16:22] Speaker F: would package. Mr. Howard. [00:16:28] Speaker E: I close the door. Well, come out. Never mind I close the door, for Pete's sake. [00:16:31] Speaker F: Thanks, Mr. Howard. [00:16:32] Speaker G: Just a little. [00:16:33] Speaker E: Close it. I'm all right in here. Get rid of him fast. I [00:16:37] Speaker G: know, [00:16:39] Speaker F: Mr. Howard. Canyon Chief. Open up, Will. [00:16:42] Speaker G: I'm coming. Yes, [00:16:47] Speaker E: Ms. Howard here. [00:16:48] Speaker G: No. Well, [00:16:49] Speaker E: I got a. [00:16:49] Speaker G: Well, I'll take it. [00:16:50] Speaker E: I'm sorry, ma'. Am. I need a signature. Well, [00:16:51] Speaker G: if you come back later. [00:16:52] Speaker E: Sure, I'll wait. [00:16:53] Speaker G: But you can't wait in here. [00:16:54] Speaker E: Look, lady, this is an important package. That's why I deliver so late at night. But, [00:16:58] Speaker G: Mr. Howard, [00:16:58] Speaker E: they told me. Get a signature. They said wait around if you have to, but make sure he gets it. Steve, [00:17:02] Speaker G: I'm sure it'll be all right if I signed it. [00:17:04] Speaker E: And I ain't so sure. Nope, lady, no go. Now, look, I'll wait. Plenty of time. Hey, what was that? [00:17:11] Speaker G: What? [00:17:12] Speaker E: I thought I heard something. [00:17:13] Speaker G: I didn't hear a thing. [00:17:14] Speaker E: Just sounds funny. Why you come from my closet as though. [00:17:17] Speaker G: Look, will you let me sign for that package, please? [00:17:19] Speaker E: I told you, lady, I got orders. Oh, strange woman's. But [00:17:22] Speaker G: I'm Mrs. Howard. [00:17:24] Speaker E: Oh, are you Mrs. Howard? Oh, that's Stephen. Why didn't you say so before? Okay, Mrs. Howard. Time, I hear. Okay, thanks. Sorry, Ms. Alex. Iris. Iris, let me out. My husband's sake, let me out. All right, I'm coming. Please. Please. I can't. Iris, let me out. I'll try. No, no, no, no. How would it matter? Tom. I'm all right. I'm all right. Only something grabbed my ankle. Something grabbed my ankle in there. No, no, no. I'm all right. Let me get my breath. Imagination. Just my imagination. I'm all right. I'm all right. The cleaning woman gone? Yes. All right. We've got to act now. Get him out of here. Come on. [00:18:21] Speaker G: What's the matter? [00:18:22] Speaker E: I don't know. What is it? The truck stop. It's locked. [00:18:26] Speaker G: What? [00:18:26] Speaker E: It's locked, Iris. [00:18:27] Speaker G: But it can't be locked. I didn't lock. Of [00:18:29] Speaker E: course you didn't. There isn't any lock on this side. The lock is. It's inside. Inside [00:18:35] Speaker F: the closet. [00:18:36] Speaker E: Oh, really? Really. This. This isn't possible. Is it a dead body locking the door behind him? Or is it? Seemed so simple at first, didn't it, Tom? Didn't it, Iris? He stood between you, blocking the way of your love. And all you have to do is get rid of him. And you did, or thought you did. But you only got rid of his life. He. He's still there. And he. Him. His body is still dangerous. You have to get rid of it. Him, don't you? And now he's prostrated you again. That's silly, isn't it? A dead man can't lock a door. Poor Tom. Poor Iris. They're trapped. Trapped in a living nightmare. Now, where were we? Oh, yes, yes, yes. Tom and Iris have murdered. And now. Now they must get rid of the body. But everything seems to be going wrong, doesn't it? First a cleaning woman and then a messenger. And now the door is locked. Who locked the door? Certainly not Peter. What did he. You know, it's like a leech, isn't it? This dead body, this. This corpse. That Won't go away. That they won't be gotten rid of. That stares and grains and. And persists in remaining on the scene. Yes. Yes. Like an Indian indestructible leech. Slowly sucking fear and. And terror from the hearts of the killers. [00:20:20] Speaker G: What time is it? [00:20:22] Speaker E: After three. [00:20:23] Speaker G: Six hours. We've been here almost six hours, Tom. Why don't we leave? We [00:20:27] Speaker E: can't leave with him in the closet. [00:20:28] Speaker G: We'll get him out, [00:20:29] Speaker E: I tell you. [00:20:29] Speaker G: Well, try again. Try it again. [00:20:35] Speaker E: Now go. [00:20:35] Speaker G: What are we going to do? [00:20:39] Speaker E: I don't know. [00:20:39] Speaker G: We can't sit here like this. [00:20:41] Speaker E: I'm thinking. [00:20:41] Speaker G: That's all you do is think. Why don't you do something? For heaven's sake, do. Good afternoon. [00:20:49] Speaker E: All right. [00:20:51] Speaker F: We'll just have to do it that way. [00:20:52] Speaker G: What way? [00:20:52] Speaker F: Force the closet door. It'll be evidence. It'll point to something wrong. But there's no other way. [00:20:56] Speaker G: Why didn't you think of this before? [00:20:58] Speaker F: But I didn't want to leave a forced door. That's why I didn't say it. Don't you understand? All [00:21:01] Speaker G: right, but let's do it. That's the only way. Now. [00:21:04] Speaker F: Ought to be something around here. I can. Well, there's [00:21:06] Speaker G: a screwdriver on the top desk drawer. [00:21:09] Speaker F: Yeah, yeah. This will do. [00:21:10] Speaker G: Tom. Tom. Look, Tom, the door. [00:21:15] Speaker F: Door. It can't be. [00:21:15] Speaker G: Yes, it is, Tom. It's opening. It's opening. He's alive. He [00:21:18] Speaker F: can't be alive. No, he can't be. If he is, he won't be much longer. Brother, you're not alive. Not after I. [00:21:25] Speaker G: What is it? [00:21:27] Speaker F: Same to this. He's dead. He's been dead for hours. [00:21:31] Speaker G: What about the door? The door, Tom? [00:21:33] Speaker F: I don't know about the door. It got stuck or something. Moisture. I don't know. Just stuck. [00:21:36] Speaker G: No, he locked it, Tom. He locked it behind me. Wouldn't [00:21:38] Speaker F: have locked it. He's dead. [00:21:39] Speaker G: He's not dead. He's alive, I tell you. He's dead, Irish. [00:21:41] Speaker F: I'll show you he's dead. Here. Here, I'll show you. There. Look at him. Look and see. He's dead, Irish. Look at him and tell me he's alive. Go on, tell me he's alive. You see? You see? He said he's got to be dead. No heart. No breath. Look. Look. I can't look. Please. Please. I'm sorry. Iris, [00:22:05] Speaker G: what are you. What are you sitting down for? [00:22:07] Speaker F: I'm tired. I'm so tired. [00:22:11] Speaker G: Tom. [00:22:12] Speaker E: Huh? [00:22:12] Speaker G: Tom, we've got to do it now. Do it now. We can't sit here. In morning, People won't be coming here. I know, Tom. We've got to get out and take him with us. [00:22:18] Speaker E: I'm so tired. [00:22:19] Speaker G: Please. Here. [00:22:24] Speaker E: All right, all right. I know. I know, Iris, but. But we won't take him. [00:22:34] Speaker G: What? [00:22:34] Speaker E: There's another way. It. Maybe a better way. I don't know why I didn't think of it before. What [00:22:39] Speaker G: do you mean? [00:22:39] Speaker E: The window. [00:22:40] Speaker G: Window? [00:22:41] Speaker E: That way. That way it'll look like suicide. We can say he came in, he looked strange, got panicky. You [00:22:47] Speaker G: think it'll work? [00:22:48] Speaker E: We have to do something, Iris. We have to take the chance. [00:22:50] Speaker G: All right. I'm tired too. Do it. Do it. Get it over. Let [00:22:53] Speaker E: me rest a minute, Tom. Huh? [00:23:01] Speaker G: Tommy, move. Don't [00:23:02] Speaker E: be crazy. I [00:23:03] Speaker G: tell you, he moved his arm. There, sir, Again. You thought. I repeat. I told you he's alive. He's [00:23:08] Speaker E: not alive, [00:23:09] Speaker G: I [00:23:09] Speaker F: tell you. It's [00:23:10] Speaker E: bigger, that's all. There's [00:23:10] Speaker F: an extra explanation for it. It happened, [00:23:12] Speaker G: I [00:23:12] Speaker F: tell you. It's rigging. I'll shut up. [00:23:19] Speaker E: All right. Help me. [00:23:22] Speaker G: I can't stop. I [00:23:23] Speaker E: didn't ask you to. Just. Just. Just open the window. [00:23:25] Speaker G: All right, [00:23:31] Speaker F: All right. Stand away. Huh? Stand aside and stop staring. Next 25 floors. That'll be good. I have to get him up, don't I? Now, just the shouting. He's got his hand on my lapel. Get him off. Off. Get him off. Come back. [00:24:02] Speaker G: Come. Oh, no, no, no. [00:24:18] Speaker F: All right, stand back there. Stand back. One side. Come on. Don't keep. What's the matter? Ain't never seen dead people before? One Harrison Bauer here. No, no, not a check in. Oh, wait a minute. We got a double jump on Verne Street. Out of an office building. Yep, 25 floors. Oh, brother. I better get us an ambulance, too. No, no, it's a third party. Woman up in the office screaming her head off. Now completely gone. Keep screaming about the dead coming to life or something. Okay, Harrison. Check. [00:24:52] Speaker E: So, you see, it's never simple, this job of killing. First of all, the victim is often less than willing. And when it's done, suppose the corpse hangs on, grinning, leering, clinging like a leech that won't be gone. Oh, yes, there is time to think before the act. But who can predict a corpse with so little tact? You are listening [00:25:23] Speaker F: to Peter Laurie in nightmare. [00:25:25] Speaker E: Well, have a good night's sleep and remember it was only a story. But tomorrow, by tomorrow, you have forgotten all about the whole thing. When you're out in the garden trimming the flowers, the rose bush, the seniors, the Irish. Oh, yes. Iris. Oh. Oh, yes. Watch out for that iris. She. I. I mean, it might be the beginning of a nightmare. [00:25:51] Speaker B: That was the leech from Nightmare here on the Mysterious Old Radio Listening Society podcast once again. I'm Eric. [00:25:58] Speaker C: I'm Tim. And I'm Joshua. [00:26:00] Speaker B: All I want is a hula hoop [00:26:03] Speaker C: for Christmas. Christmas, [00:26:05] Speaker B: that is [00:26:06] Speaker C: Alvin. [00:26:09] Speaker B: That was. Who brought that? Joshua. [00:26:11] Speaker C: Joshua. Yeah, [00:26:12] Speaker B: yeah, yeah. So this is part of our 10 shows that we've never done before. Right. Nightmares escaped me. I didn't even know it existed until you sent this over to me. I never even heard of it. [00:26:25] Speaker C: I knew of its existence, but I. [00:26:27] Speaker D: You kept it from us. [00:26:28] Speaker C: I hid it well. Also because as a great lover of Peter Lorre, it's fun to hear him host. It's always a little disappointing when he stops talking. [00:26:37] Speaker B: Yes, yes. But how many of these exist? Do we know? I know I'm probably putting you on the spot, but is this you [00:26:45] Speaker C: are, you son of a gun. I think it's in the teens, maybe last year. At least [00:26:50] Speaker D: one. [00:26:50] Speaker C: Yeah. [00:26:51] Speaker B: And how long did it run again? [00:26:52] Speaker C: Just for about a year. 53 to 54. [00:26:55] Speaker D: Who did the Foley effects for? [00:26:58] Speaker B: Who was the third grip? I'm asking those questions because in our world of old time radio, if there's a significant amount of them in existence, we all seem to have heard of it. And that seems like a significant. I [00:27:14] Speaker C: think part of it is I listened to maybe four or five episodes before I settled on this, and from those, I get the impression that Nightmare featured fairly generic stories, competently told, and any reputation it has is on the back of Peter Lorre as host. That being said, I picked this one because of those four or five. I definitely thought this was the most enjoyable. Again, the hard thing is, when you are picking an episode, the context you're presenting it in is the six or seven others you chose not to. You guys did not hear the ones I turned down. So I'm always presenting it as if you had heard these others. Right, [00:27:55] Speaker B: right. [00:27:55] Speaker C: Why aren't you thanking me? [00:27:57] Speaker B: Well, we have that coming up next week, that same scenario with me. Here's my biggest disappointment. I was really hoping that, like, the Blob, there was going to be a giant leech. [00:28:10] Speaker C: See, I knew that right away. I knew there was a problem with that title and with Peter Lorre's intro. [00:28:16] Speaker B: Yeah. [00:28:17] Speaker C: Even though at the end he's like. But it's a leech who's a man that's dead. [00:28:22] Speaker B: Yeah. A giant leech. Would have been sweet even for radio. Just listening to that thing moving along was sucking some slurp. Yeah. [00:28:35] Speaker C: Yes. So I realize that's a massive disappointment that you had to overcome and I applaud you for presumably doing it. [00:28:45] Speaker B: I did. And then. But the good news is. Oh. So someone still has not written the leech the way I want it. So get ready boys, because [00:28:55] Speaker C: our giant size leech thing number one. [00:28:57] Speaker B: Yep. We are gonna do it. Yeah. But I did get over it to the point of I thought that was pretty good. [00:29:05] Speaker D: I actually quite enjoyed this. I was happily surprised by the setup. Seemed so. Not predictable, but it seemed so canned of we have to tell our husband, my husband about our affair and he already knows and I'm gonna ruin you. And I really felt like I've heard this radio story 400 times and then was taken by surprise like, oh, and he's dead. And that's a totally different problem now. [00:29:30] Speaker C: Yes. And I think that's where it comes to life. It stays. [00:29:35] Speaker D: It's a one act. [00:29:36] Speaker C: Yeah. I [00:29:37] Speaker D: mean it is one set real time. It's great. [00:29:40] Speaker C: And while it is intimate and small, it has the life and death stakes of we've killed a man, we've got to hide the body or we're gonna. [00:29:48] Speaker D: And it suddenly grants a station in this office. Right. At [00:29:52] Speaker C: two in the. Two in the morning. [00:29:55] Speaker B: Right. I like that line Laurie has. You know that something about killing a man or killing somebody. And their first problem is they're usually against it. I'm paraphrasing, but I like that. [00:30:10] Speaker C: Another reason I picked this one is Peter Lorre seems to be savoring the monologue a little more than some of the others. Some are fairly phoned in. [00:30:20] Speaker B: In [00:30:20] Speaker C: this one he seems to be a little more sardonic and having a touch more fun. [00:30:26] Speaker D: And the monologue had some nice writing in there. The keys that can get you locked up. Comparing the escaping this room versus being locked up for in prison because they might go to jail because they killed a guy. I could further explain how the legal system in America works if anyone needs. [00:30:47] Speaker B: I don't understand why it is so bad to phone something in. [00:30:56] Speaker D: There's one logic problem. I feel like I need to point this out. The one plot problem is they point out that the guy has not been to the office before. This is your first time visiting my office, he tells him. And yet he knows the cleaning woman has keys. He claims to have forgotten that, but for some reason he is was previously supposed to be aware of that. A cleaning woman has keys to the office. I said, aha. Logic problem. [00:31:19] Speaker B: Right. [00:31:20] Speaker D: Felt very proud of myself. [00:31:21] Speaker B: Yes. [00:31:22] Speaker C: I just assumed that was just general office knowledge. If you work in an office, you know that cleaning ladies have keys to clean. [00:31:28] Speaker D: You're off the hook. [00:31:30] Speaker B: She was like, if, hey, you don't have to clean, okay, that should be the end of this. She really [00:31:38] Speaker A: adamantly [00:31:38] Speaker B: wanted to clean. But I [00:31:39] Speaker D: usually get my tip. [00:31:41] Speaker B: Yeah, 20 bucks back then. Did you do the math? Did you do the. [00:31:45] Speaker C: No, [00:31:46] Speaker B: I did. It's $8 million. [00:31:49] Speaker D: Pretty good tip. [00:31:50] Speaker B: Yeah. A lot of money to carry around in your pocket. [00:31:54] Speaker D: I also appreciated that at the very top, you see the friction between these two characters that like, we allegedly love each other so much that we're going to. I'm going to divorce my husband. We're going to go off together. That just a little hint of that. As soon as there's a real challenge that they are at each other, that blows up. And I felt like that added a little depth to just the sort of event based goings on of the plot [00:32:20] Speaker C: and the way they interacted. You also could tell that they've been having an affair for a while. [00:32:27] Speaker D: We've lost the magic. [00:32:29] Speaker C: Yeah, right. Lived in quality. This affair has. Right, right. When he's like, we have to tell your husband. It's like, okay, let's go. We're. Wait, you want me to go to. And. And there's that moment too when the husband offers him a drink and he's like, oh, yeah, that'd be nice. We're not here to drink. [00:32:46] Speaker B: He will not have that. Also, [00:32:48] Speaker C: it's like, wait, I think you guys are already married. [00:32:51] Speaker B: We could break this door down. Well, why didn't you tell me that earlier? Well, because I was thinking this. Well, fine. Well, now you have thought of it. So let's break the door down. Fine, I'll break the door down. That really was a married conversation. That is the [00:33:03] Speaker D: fun part of this show. [00:33:04] Speaker B: Yeah. [00:33:04] Speaker C: Yeah. It's definitely one of those suspense horror stories that illuminate that fine line between suspense, horror and comedy. [00:33:13] Speaker D: Yes, yes. [00:33:14] Speaker C: I also liked some of the trust they had. Again, it's the 50s in listeners for following along with sound effects and filling in the action without narration. Like the struggle and fight between the lover and the husband, whose names I'm forgetting. No one says you stabbed him with a letter opener. You strangled him. Presumably it all sounded physical. He was strangled to death. But there's a similar quality to gun smoke at its best too, when physical altercations are not described and you can kind of create your own subtle version, but you can also [00:33:52] Speaker B: assume no blood. [00:33:53] Speaker C: Yes. [00:33:54] Speaker D: When the cleaning lady came in, you figure out from clues of where the body is and why she's not seeing them. [00:34:01] Speaker C: Yes. Cause he says, don't go behind the desk. [00:34:03] Speaker D: Yes. And [00:34:03] Speaker C: then you're like, [00:34:04] Speaker D: because that's why I've hit in the button. Ah, [00:34:06] Speaker C: damn it. You should have had that drink. Be so much more relaxed now. So it has a lot of the elements of later radio drama that I like, but it hasn't quite crossed that line where they've just given up and they're like, yep, I'm gonna slightly rewrite the mysterious traveler again. [00:34:29] Speaker B: Right. [00:34:30] Speaker D: To pivot to my other side of my thinking. The whole idea of how did this door get locked from the inside? How did the door get unlocked from the inside? Is this body mysteriously doing things? It falls on the side of pointlessly vague without really saying anything, as opposed to compellingly ambiguous. That makes you wonder. Makes you want to fill in the details in your own mind. To me, it just seemed like that I didn't really suss that out. It's kind of an unfinished sketch. [00:34:59] Speaker C: I see what you mean. Because of that. I read it all as a telltale heart type of thing, that this was just guilt and panic. And what they were describing was all in their [00:35:14] Speaker D: self inflicted [00:35:15] Speaker C: in their heads. Yeah. I didn't even sense any ambiguity to it. Probably because of the way you're describing it. And if they wanted me to go, is it. Could it be? Then, yes, they failed. Eric's giving us some weird eyes. [00:35:30] Speaker B: I didn't follow that at all. [00:35:32] Speaker D: You know how the bodies get put in the closet then. Wait, the closet's locked. How is the closet locked? It locked from the inside. How did that happen? Mysterious. [00:35:40] Speaker B: And [00:35:40] Speaker D: then later on, they have the problem. Like, we're just going to bust the closet door down. [00:35:44] Speaker B: And [00:35:44] Speaker D: the closet door opens by itself. [00:35:46] Speaker B: Yes. [00:35:46] Speaker D: How did the closet door open? [00:35:47] Speaker C: And at the end, he says the hand grabs him by the lapel as he's trying to throw it out the window. [00:35:53] Speaker B: What about all that? He's back from the dead. [00:35:56] Speaker D: All right. [00:35:57] Speaker C: See, we came down very different. [00:35:59] Speaker B: You guys are discussing what is going on. [00:36:03] Speaker C: Yeah, we were saying it's not that mysterious. We didn't feel like they really pushed us too hard to question whether it was supernatural or not. I just assumed it was them in their panic and guilt, imagining these. [00:36:17] Speaker B: I assumed it was supernatural 100% [00:36:20] Speaker D: that he [00:36:21] Speaker B: was wronged and he was. [00:36:22] Speaker C: Information bias. [00:36:26] Speaker B: You know, that he Was haunting them. [00:36:29] Speaker C: Everything to be supernatural. [00:36:30] Speaker B: Yeah, [00:36:31] Speaker D: I love that point of view of like, these people killed me. I'm gonna [00:36:34] Speaker C: lock [00:36:35] Speaker D: myself in the [00:36:35] Speaker C: closet and I'm going to. There's one point like, I'm gonna touch his leg. [00:36:41] Speaker B: Yeah, he's effing with them. [00:36:44] Speaker C: So that's what made me think it was in their head. Those little moments where he said, I thought I felt something touch me. It just didn't seem very threatening. [00:36:54] Speaker B: Yeah, I took it as supernatural 100%. That's interesting. That's what I thought this was about. [00:36:59] Speaker C: Because [00:37:00] Speaker B: it [00:37:01] Speaker C: increases as their panic increases. [00:37:04] Speaker B: So, yeah, I can see that. That it's self imposed through panic that they. [00:37:10] Speaker D: I can't open the door. [00:37:11] Speaker B: Can't open the door [00:37:11] Speaker D: too much. [00:37:12] Speaker B: Yeah, I guess it's not nearly as fun. [00:37:15] Speaker C: And again, to use my Telltale Heart comparison, by the end, she's just gibbering and screaming because, you know, she could still try to get out of this. Like these two men were fighting and they threw themselves wrestling out the window. But she's just completely snapped at that point. [00:37:31] Speaker B: Right. [00:37:31] Speaker D: With what the cop disturbingly calls like, double jump. How many of these do you have? [00:37:39] Speaker C: He also says, what's the matter with you? Ain't you ever seen dead people before? To the crowd gathering around. Yeah. [00:37:46] Speaker B: Right. [00:37:47] Speaker C: So, yes, it's a very callous cop. Again, I found the entire production to teeter into dark comedy. And I don't mean that in a negative way. I think that's part of what made it exciting and fun and a little different from the others I listened to. And none of them are terrible, generic, competently done horror suspense stories. [00:38:09] Speaker B: I will say that 22 minutes was the max amount of plot there was to this. [00:38:16] Speaker D: Yes. That's my main critique is it lost some steam as it went. [00:38:21] Speaker B: Yeah. [00:38:21] Speaker D: Liked it quite a bit to begin with. And it kind of a little bit just petered out. [00:38:25] Speaker B: Singing telegram. Like that was just a series of interruptions that can. [00:38:31] Speaker C: Yeah. And again, it's farcical because with each new intruder, they cement their position as people who are in this office at this time. The cleaning lady, they can give her a tip. She signs for a package, presumably that has the time on it as well. [00:38:49] Speaker D: They are acting strange. Unforgettable. Yes, definitely. I saw this person here at this time [00:38:55] Speaker C: semi farcical. And I love how everybody, including the cleaning lady, are like, oh, you guys are having an [00:39:02] Speaker D: affair. [00:39:03] Speaker C: Husband knows, like as soon as they give her 10 bucks, she's like, oh, [00:39:08] Speaker D: I'll [00:39:08] Speaker C: close the door behind [00:39:09] Speaker D: Me, you've probably killed her husband. I think I'm open to hearing more of these. I know you did some filtering for us and I might regret that, but not too bad. [00:39:20] Speaker C: Yeah, I think it was pretty good. Peter Lorre, even at one point in this one comes through and I think he actually uses the word silly. Come on, now, that's silly. A corpse locking himself in a closet. So it has that tongue in cheek quality that is quite enjoyable. But yeah, I think the coda was a little underwhelming and there's a gibbering lady upstairs, but yeah, it's a little slight, I realize. And maybe that's another reason we choose the episodes and the series that we choose is because we need to somehow eke, at bare minimum a 20 minute conversation out of it. [00:39:59] Speaker B: Yeah, I mean, [00:39:59] Speaker C: some of these that I've listened to, I've gone, oh, that's why we've never bribed on this before in 10 years. [00:40:05] Speaker D: Nevermind. We should indulge ourselves in one of these episodes and that's the episode we listen to. What do you guys think? [00:40:10] Speaker B: Right. [00:40:11] Speaker D: All right. [00:40:12] Speaker B: Yeah. [00:40:13] Speaker D: Tim, tell him stuff. We owe ourselves that. [00:40:17] Speaker C: Yeah, I think so. [00:40:18] Speaker B: But there's a lot of truth to that, that this is pretty cut and dried. Other than I think the most conversation little thing from this is how wrong you guys are that it wasn't supernatural [00:40:31] Speaker C: and we might be. I just felt like the evidence says [00:40:34] Speaker B: Zombie guy. [00:40:36] Speaker D: Your argument that it is the most fun interpretation is compelling. [00:40:39] Speaker B: Zombie came back to life, grabbed him, threw him out. The wind went. I'm going too. I think at the end, you know, when they're on the sidewalk. Should have got up and walked away. [00:40:49] Speaker C: Dusted himself off. Right. [00:40:51] Speaker B: I'm dead. See, [00:40:53] Speaker C: you'll like the battle of the magicians from lights out. [00:40:58] Speaker B: Oh, yeah, yeah. [00:40:59] Speaker C: Zombie just drops from the plane, [00:41:00] Speaker B: right. [00:41:01] Speaker C: Gets up, thump. [00:41:04] Speaker B: Well, should we vote? [00:41:05] Speaker C: Yeah, let's vote. [00:41:06] Speaker B: I. I'll give this a solid B minus. I actually think this Stand the test of time and for a lot of reasons. I think it's pretty Pablomy standard suspense stuff. Even if you go with the supernatural angle and say that's what it was and that's fact. It's still pretty standardy stuff, but overall it's okay. It's good. It may not have had 22 minutes of solid plot in it. Not a classic. [00:41:34] Speaker C: Yeah, I think it Stand the test of time for sure. Definitely not a classic. It was fun. It was, like I said, very spare in ways that were pleasing, but possibly also just a little Too slight. Not quite enough meat on its bones to sustain its length. But it's a minor critique. It's hard not to compare a story like this to the kind of stories and the kind of productions on suspense it reminded me of. I think I'm going to get the name wrong. It was something with a tip. But the suspense episode in which the killer held the wife hostage [00:42:11] Speaker D: and [00:42:11] Speaker C: people kept coming to the door and she had to get rid of them. Is that what [00:42:16] Speaker D: it's [00:42:16] Speaker C: called? Yes. I'll pretend you're not having sex if you give me a $10 tip. Yeah. And so I can imagine this done slightly better. And that's not really a fair way to judge this, but I judge it a little. So Stand the test of time. [00:42:37] Speaker D: Yeah. I'm on board with everything you guys said in our individual context of we're venturing out to other series we haven't heard before. It's always a treat to find a new series that you like, even if it's just, like, pretty good. That's great because there are so many series out there. Like, this is not good. I'm glad we don't do much of this, but this was a nice surprise. Dance test of time, not a classic [00:42:59] Speaker B: Tim, tell him stuff. [00:43:00] Speaker D: Please go visit ghoulishdelights.com or please, you know, it's nice. You'll find other things. Other episodes we've done there, like 400 plus. Oh my goodness. We've done so many episodes and you can find them there. But you can find those anywhere you listen to podcasts. I mean, we're just lousy with podcast sources material. But you can also find a link to our store. If you want to buy something with our logo on it, get a T shirt or a hoodie, a varsity jacket. It's there. You can have one of them. Oh, and you'll find a link to our Patreon page. [00:43:33] Speaker C: Yes. I'm sorry, I'm laughing because you were like, we've done 400 some episodes. And then what happens is I know a few people. Or we also have patrons who go back and listen or some friends who are listening to this out of order. And a friend of mine who started listening to the podcast right now just sent me a text, said in episode 348, the gorilla man, Eric says that the groundhogs and hedgehogs are the same. They are not. I'm not sure if it was a Joker series, but now I'm yelling. I don't remember their context. I don't remember anything [00:44:10] Speaker D: Tolstoy was the hedgehog, right? [00:44:11] Speaker C: Yes. Englishy yes. Go to patreon.com themorals and you can send us texts taking us to task for this no longer remember anymore. [00:44:31] Speaker B: The Mysterious Old Radio Listening Society Theater Company also performs live on stage recreations of classic old time radio shows and a lot of our own original work. We're always performing somewhere. Go to ghoulishdelights.com and find out where we're performing, when, what, how to get tickets. It's all there. Ghoulishdelights.com we perform probably 12 to 15 times a year. Come see us do live audio drama. What's coming up next? Your [00:44:58] Speaker D: choice next. [00:44:58] Speaker B: Oh yeah. We are continuing with our stuff we've never done before. What's it called? 10 for 10. [00:45:04] Speaker D: Sure. [00:45:05] Speaker B: Anyway, we're going to do Bulldog Drummond and episode called Death Wears Mysterious Disappearing Ink. No wait, what's it called? [00:45:16] Speaker D: Death Uses Disappearing Ink. [00:45:18] Speaker B: Ooh, you should have brought this one. You know more about it than I do. Until then, [00:45:24] Speaker H: look out. [00:45:25] Speaker B: Listen to the sounds coming from the speaker. Listen to the music and listen to the voices and listen to that.

Other Episodes

Episode 95

August 09, 2018 • 00:58:04
Episode Cover

Episode 95: It Happened

We’re running a little late this week—out humblest apologies! Our Listener Library is again featured in this week. This time, we’re listening to “It...

Listen

Episode 272

October 12, 2022 • 00:59:57
Episode Cover

Episode 272: The Doctor Prescribed Death

This October is our Patreon pledge drive and we continue to try to entice you to support us via Patreon with this, the only...

Listen

Episode 208

March 11, 2021 • 01:02:57
Episode Cover

Episode 208: The Louis Spence Case

This episode is the fourth of our four-part series featuring one of our Patreon members who supports us at the highest level! This time,...

Listen